And this speaks to the larger problem that no one wants to talk about: the restoration of the Roman rite is a precondition for a long-term fix for the problem.
Even Catholic parishes today are not wanting for talent. But no serious singer or organist will get anywhere near the typical music program, at least if he wants to retain his self-respect.
The democratic and pedestrian character of the new Mass itself seems to invite the ditties that pass for hymns these days.
But nowadays hymns are the norm, because people don't have much else to sing.
At St. Francis de Sales in Atlanta, we do not have an organ. We do not have rehearsals during the week. We do not have a professional choir.
As for sacred polyphony, there is no reason to be afraid of it.
Ironically, we live in times that are awash in authentic sacred music.
You can count on one hand the number of Novus Ordo churches in this country that feature a fully Catholic music program of any quality, consistent with the Roman rite tradition.